Architectural Roof vs Regular Roof

If you’re looking at getting a new roof anytime soon and have your mind set on getting nice new roof shingles, the next question you have in mind is probably whether you should get an architectural roof or a regular roof. Or if you’re new to roofing, you probably are now asking – what’s the difference?

When choosing a new roof, the type of shingles that you choose affects how your home will look and even the value of your property. There are different types of asphalt roof shingles to choose from, however, the main types are 3-tab shingles or architectural shingles. Between these 2 options, 3-tab shingles are cheaper and more cost effective. However, there are some advantages to getting architectural shingles, aside from the improved aesthetics of your home. When making a choice between these 2 types of shingles, it is best to keep the following information in mind as you compare your residential roofing options.

architectural roof vs regular roof

Option 1 – 3-Tab Shingles

This type of shingle is one of the most common types used for residential roofing. 3-tab shingles are a commonly used option for many homeowners because of the more affordable cost. However, the low cost comes with a few disadvantages that we will go over. 

One of the drawbacks is that 3-tab shingles have limited warranty coverage. In the long run, you will probably have to cover the full costs of any repairs for your roof. Or, you will also need to replace your roof much sooner since this type of roof shingle also has a shorter lifespan when compared to architectural shingles. You can expect your 3-tab shingles to last around 25 years.

Aside from the limited warranty and shorter lifespan, these shingles are also less durable. On the one hand, they are lightweight making these much easier to install. But, because of these properties, they are also more likely to be carried off, removed, or damaged by strong wind and debris. Over time, these shingles are also more prone to curling along the edges.

Lastly, 3-tab shingles tend to give homes a dull, uniform appearance. While this isn’t a bad thing, you can easily tell the difference between the quality of a home with 3-tab shingles and one with architectural shingles which is probably why the latter option costs more. 

Option 2 – Architectural Shingles

Aside from 3-tab shingles, another common alternative is the use of architectural shingles. Architectural shingles provide a more dimensional appearance that can improve the overall aesthetic of your property. Compared to 3-tab shingles, architectural shingles weigh more. On the downside, this makes it a bit more difficult to install. However, it also gives your roof better durability and strength to withstand harsh weather conditions. Aside from these benefits, architectural shingles also offer more advantages for homeowners.

When choosing architectural shingles, there are actually much more options in terms of color, size, and shape. This gives you a better chance to customize the look of your home. Additionally, architectural shingles also have better warranty coverage that typically last 30 years or even 50 years for some brands – that is almost double the length of coverage that you would usually get for 3-tab shingles.

While it is definitely obvious that architectural shingles are a better option, the main problem to consider is whether the additional cost of getting architectural shingles is actually worth it. 

One of the potential drawbacks of architectural shingles is their higher cost compared to 3-tab shingles. Is it worth the extra money to have architectural shingles installed on your home? We believe architectural shingles are worth the extra cost for a few different reasons, including the following:

  • Added resale value
  • Versatile design
  • High-end standard
  • Sophisticated appearance

On top of these benefits, there is also the need to think about the long term costs that come with these types of roofing. Now that you understand the differences in the warranties and durability factors between the two types of shingles, you need to think about the long-term costs. While 3-tab shingles seems like a cheaper option at the start, architectural shingles are more durable, last longer, and have better warranties. In the long term, where do you think you get to save more? 

Do you need more help choosing the right shingles for your home? At Waddle Exteriors, we offer dependable, high-quality residential roofing services and installations. Our experienced roofers can help you choose the ideal shingle color and design to improve your home’s appearance and value.

Related Articles